Fug or Fab: Melissa George


fug-or-fab

First of all, yes, that is Russell Simmons leaning out of frame — I have a tendency to forget they are dating until they show up somewhere holding hands and my mind is blown anew:

Is it weird that I kind of like this? Yes, yes, it kind of looks like it’s on backwards, and it sort of implies that her torso is a stage, and her boobs are the opening act, but…I don’t know. It’s sort of slinky and interesting and cape-like, and you know I love a cape, especially during Halloween season.

So let's crowd-source this thing:

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

[Photo: Splash]

react:
Leave a reply

Comments (29):

  1. LoriK

    I wish I could have picked 2 things in the poll, because I think this dress is not working but I also had no idea they were dating and I can’t quite wrap my head around it.

  2. Susan

    Considering how fug she usually looks, this is definitely a win for MG.

    Question: how many years will it be before I can see a photo of her and not instantly think, “she married Vaughn!!”

    • Jenny

      who is Vaughn? I even went over to imdb.com to try and figure out what that meant – no luck. please explain! I hate missing some clever reference!
      not crazy about the draping, the neck looks almost ghastly old lady style cape then surprise midriff reveal – ehh – the skirt looks great until it does that weird puddle that looks tucked in on itself at the bottom, wish I had her hips, but. Very impressed that the dress and her lipstick don’t clash with the red carpet, the gradient of reds is almost pleasing. I think I’d even like it if it didn’t appear to fold in on itself at the bottom, like very very long harem pants or something. And she looks beautiful but there’s something offputting about the sort of “who me?” pose. Because who wears a dress like that and then goes “oh who, little old me?” at a photographer? but she does look beautiful.

      • Sajorina

        Vaughn was the character played by Michael Vartan that Melissa’s character was married to on “Alias”! He was Jennifer Garner character’s CIA handler!

  3. annabeth

    I like the dress. Bold red is always her best shade, and while the draping on this could easily go wrong, I think it actually hits the right balance of being slightly revealing but still classic.

  4. vandalfan

    A droopy satin sack, and sneakers with red carpet formal wear is tres gauche and so Jonah Brothers. I don’t want to admire the solar plexus or midriff, and I heartily second the statement that anything requiring industrial strength boob tape is poorly designed. And don’t the gaping sleeves make sideboob an inevitable reality?

  5. anonymoose

    What kind of a loser wears sneakers with a suit? A loser’s loser, that’s what kind. GACK.

  6. Kara

    Wait wait wait wait WAIT. Russell Simmons and Melissa George are dating? How did I not know this? And how did this happen? This is like when Quentin Tarantino was dating Shar Jackson.

    • Ana

      Quentin Tarantino was dating Shar Jackson?!

      • Mahastee

        I’m sure I just saw her like two months ago, cooing about how much she loves her husband?

        She gives me the creeps, unfortunately. I’d love to be able to cheer on a fellow Aussie.

  7. Chris

    All three apply.

    This is high drama.

    I really am not sure about the draping.

    HOW THE FUCK DID MELISSA GEORGE AND RUSSELL FUCKING SIMMONS HAPPEN

    Also, while I love a good pair of Adidas (I may get a pair of shell toes again), I would never pair them with a suit. EVER.

  8. Geemee

    I voted for “They’re DATING?” because THEY’RE DATING? Where was I when that happened? What on earth do they have to talk about? Yoga, I guess.

    BTW, she looks dead. Like, as white as his shoes, which I want to stomp on while wearing muddy boots. Here’s hoping it’s the camera flash.

  9. anny

    @vandalfan – as so often, you’ve said it for me.
    I would just add that I DON’T CARE IF THEY’RE FREAKING GLOW IN THE DARK SUPER GLEEMY WHITE FORMAL sneakers, they don’t belong on a red carpet once the event has begun. (They do sort of match her sternum, though.)

  10. megs283

    better than Richard Simmons, which is who I thought you were talking about until I googled him…

  11. Lulu

    I voted Fab because I like the dress…but I do wish her face wasn’t so shiny, with the high-necked red dress and red lipstick it’s a bit much.

  12. Fuh Ugh

    Russell Simmons always dresses like Urkel (except his pants are long enough). It’s his schtick, so you kinda have to give him that. It’s like Diane Keaton with the gloves or Swinton with the lack of makeup.

    I think Melissa George is allllllllmost carrying this off. Except. It does her boobs no favors. Where is that left one pointing? It’s like a lazy eye or something – so distracting.

  13. Laucie

    If it were a black and white photo, this look could be a still from any Sunday afternoon’s TCM offerings.

  14. Workout Wear Slogan

    Its fabulous, According to my personal point of view the color & design of the dress are too good man .I also like the carrying sense to carry this dress………..

  15. flirtydivatees

    flirtydivatees.com says , I voted fabulous because I like the dress .Its tremendous.Because I always like the dress in bold red..

  16. NYCGirl

    I also didn’t know they were dating, but the fugliness of the dress outweighs my surprise at the pairing.

  17. fitnessfreak

    Workout Wear Slogan TeesI voted for fab because .I like this dress & color also

  18. Sajorina

    I think it’s FABULOUS! But, I thought she was married to a Chilean guy, so WTF happened? Russell Simmons? Really? *dumbfounded*

    And, who the hell wears Adidas to a Ball?

  19. Emily

    Every time you post about Melissa George I read it as Regina George. And then I get weirdly disappointed that it isn’t Rachel McAdams in something pink with a bitchy expression on her face…

  20. Alice

    I still can’t look at her without fuming about Alias season 3. I shouldn’t hold her responsible, but I sort of do.

    I don’t like the dress, but I think the shoes are a great match for it.

  21. val.

    This is a little too Samantha from SATC for me.

    And I had no idea they’re dating.

  22. Gigi

    Does Kimora Lee know? Melissa better be super nice to the kiddos, because otherwise, that crazy ex wife is one major reason why dating Russell Simmons would be a major risk.

    I like the dress, if only because it is Halloween.

    • Bevvie Hedstrom

      “I like the dress, if only because it is Halloween.”

      I like the dress ONLY because it is Halloween.

  23. Emily

    I have a gorgeous bag just like that from http://www.st8ment.co.uk Doesn’t make the dress work though!

  24. burntcopper

    …This is pretty much a direct copy of a dress from the Hollywood Golden Age. Rita Hayworth wore it, I think.